A clear rule
The rule fits into a few sentences and cannot be read two ways. If the rule has to be explained through examples, that is already a reason to be careful.
An independent magazine about classic logic puzzles on paper and on screen. It is not a gaming portal, hosts no games or files and is not connected with the former site on this domain.
Reviews
We do not give scores or draw up lists of the best puzzles. Instead, we describe the features that show a puzzle was made with respect for the person solving it. These features will help you both when choosing a collection for the evening and when checking a puzzle you have invented yourself.
A fair puzzle can be very hard, but it never makes you guess. Everything you need for the answer is already in the rule.
How this section works: here you will find only the features of a good puzzle, with no verdicts on particular games or apps. Apply them yourself to any puzzle on paper or on screen.
Features that set a well-thought-out puzzle apart from a haphazard one.
The rule fits into a few sentences and cannot be read two ways. If the rule has to be explained through examples, that is already a reason to be careful.
A good puzzle has exactly one answer, reached by a chain of deductions. If there are many answers, the solver cannot be sure of having found the intended one.
The challenge comes from the depth of reasoning, not from hidden rules or small print. Each step follows from the one before.
The puzzle can realistically be solved with a pencil on paper in a reasonable time. If there is no way round a program's exhaustive search, it is more a calculation than a puzzle.
Eight queens (in Russian)
A good hint shows where to look but does not do the work for you. We value puzzles that allow a hint like that.
The last move should feel like a click: everything fits, and it is clear why. That is the main reason people solve puzzles.
| Feature | Probably fair | Worth a closer look |
|---|---|---|
| Rule | Short and unambiguous | Needs caveats and exceptions |
| Solution | Exactly one | Several answers or none |
| Difficulty | Grows from step to step | Relies on guessing |
| Tools | A pencil is enough | Impossible without a program's search |
| Hints | Point the way but do not solve | Give the whole answer away |
Solve the puzzle yourself, noting every deduction. If at some step you had to choose between two equally valid options and both led to the end without a contradiction, the puzzle has more than one solution.
For a puzzle of your own, ask a friend to solve it without hints and talk you through their thinking. If their answer differs from yours but also fits the rule, the rule needs one more constraint.
Families of puzzles, with no commercial titles: mazes, placement problems, number grids, sliding puzzles, matchsticks and weighing problems.
How to approach each type of puzzle, step by step and without ready-made answers. The magazine's article catalogue is here too.
A solver's techniques: a small version, ruling out the impossible, symmetry, writing moves down, backtracking and a well-timed break.
Answers about the magazine, about how to solve and where people most often get stuck, and about puzzles for children and families.
The magazine describes techniques that suit whole families of puzzles. Particular collections and apps sometimes word their rules in their own way, so before you start, reread the rule of the exact puzzle in front of you.